Comma Inside Quotes With Question Mark
What would you do if the title with a question mark was in quotes, rather than italicized? In the second example, when a question or exclamation mark comes at the end of a sentence, there’s no need for an additional ending punctuation after the quote marks.
In the united states, we always put periods and commas inside quotation marks, but twice in the last week i've seen writers break this rule when confronted with a quotation that ended with a question mark and also needed a comma after it to make the whole sentence work.here's an example from this week's grammar girl podcast and article about christmas carols:
Comma inside quotes with question mark. 92 of the 6th ed. Commas and periods that are part of the overall sentence go inside the quotation marks, even though they aren’t part of the original quotation. In contrast with the examples above, when the question mark is part of a title of work, a syntactically necessary comma is retained.
The mla handbook notes, “by convention, commas and periods that directly follow quotations go inside the closing quotation marks” (88). Whether a question mark or an exclamation point should appear inside or outside the quotation marks depends on the meaning. In the example given in the question, the list is of a series of terms, or 'elements'.
Quotation marks and other punctuation marks. January 8, 2018 at 9:24 am the comma would be placed inside the quotation marks. This is a case in which the accepted british and american english authorities appear to offer conflicting advice (but see final paragraph).
She asked, will you still be my friend? the question will you still be my friend? The rule is the same for a list of titles: Because the colon and question mark are part of the quotes, they’re included inside the quotation marks.
Question marks and exclamation points require you to think about the sentence a little to determine where they go. If you quote a question, put the question mark inside the quotation marks. *place other punctuation inside quotation marks when that punctuation is part of what is being quoted, such as a quoted question.
Did she say, “may i go?” pop quiz. Does punctuation go inside quotation marks? Semicolons, colons, and dashes always go outside the closing quotation mark.
Read on to find out why and lessen the confusion Commas and periods always go inside the quotation marks. The answer is both yes and no!
Check with your favorite style guide Question marks and exclamation marks are place according to the sentence in question. This rule makes good sense;
Would the comma go inside or outside the quotation mark? Since the question is not inside the quotation marks, the question mark goes outside. These rules have no exceptions.
Quotation mark image courtesy of shutterstock. It distinguishes a quoted question from a quotation embedded in a question. Thus, in the following sentence, the comma is placed after taught:
For example, the man continued, the sky is purple today. my question concerns the use of punctuation when the thing within the quotation marks is a specific technical thing. Whether these punctuation marks go inside or outside quotation marks depends on context. Time to look at one more part of betsy’s encounter with the falling piano.
Only the quoted material is a question, so the question mark belongs only to the quote and must remain within the quotation marks.) exclamation marks follow the same rule as question marks. In cases when a question mark is used, there is no need to use a comma as well; (the comma would go outside the quotation marks for bre.) the comma is still necessary in this case because the question mark is not replacing it.
The comma or period at the end of the quotation should always be placed inside the quotation marks. Publication manual), as do several other major style guides (such as ap, chicago, and mla).the table below elaborates, with examples for each punctuation mark. In american english, periods go inside quotation marks.
Is part of the quotation. Do you agree with the saying, all's fair in love. The song asks, “would you like to swing on a star.
Style in placing commas inside quotation marks instead of outside them. The rules for punctuation with quotation marks are covered both in the hard copy blue book of grammar and punctuation as well as on our grammarbook.com website. If the quote is a question or exclamation, the punctuation mark goes inside the quotation marks.
As you might guess from our name, apa style uses american style punctuation (see p. The song asks, “would you like to swing on a star?” 1b. In the uk, the tendency is to place them outside.
Yes, the comma goes inside the quotation marks and after the question mark because the question mark is part of the periodical’s title. Periods and commas always go inside the closing quotation mark (in american english). Instead, the attributive tag should come immediately after the closing quotation marks.
Inside of the quotation mark in quoted speech. In the us, periods and commas are placed inside quotation marks. If a question is within the quoted material, a question mark should be placed inside the quotation marks.
For example, the correct computer password is abcd!. Julio cortázar wrote many short stories, including “la noche boca arriba. Colons and semicolons are placed outside quotations, while question marks and exclamation marks follow the logic of the sentence.
This page has examples showing the different conventions for placing punctuation inside or outside quotation marks. “you’ve got to be carefully taught,” wrote oscar hammerstein ii. Colons and semicolons should be outside the quotation marks.
The comma is the mark most frequently used to introduce quoted material. However, this is not always the case with exclamation points and question marks. This situation wouldn't arise under chicago rules because chicago follows general u.s.
Does punctuation go inside or outside quotation marks? Note in the first example below that when the question mark is part of the title of a work that is set in italics, as it is in the cited novel, the question mark is italicized. The placement of question marks with quotation marks follows logic.
If the question is part of the quote then the question mark goes inside the quotes, if the question is about the quote the question mark is placed outside the quotes. If you follow these three rules, you will always be correct when using quotation marks with other forms of punctuation. If i am not mistaken, one should insert a period, question mark, etc.
The piano mover answered betsy, but no one could understand his words.
